What Are The Best Breast Pumps? – Let’s Review!
After your baby is born, nurses at the hospital or birthing center will help your nurse your baby the first few times so that they and you can get accustomed to them latching on and feeding directly from your breast.
Feeding your baby is one of the most important things that as a mother, or parent you can do to help your baby grow big and strong, especially in the first few days of their life.
For some babies and mothers, latching doesn’t always work, whether it is frustration, preference or if the baby has a medical issue. Because of this, there are many choices on the market offering breast pumps to help you express the milk in your breasts and help feed your baby.
But when you start the process of buying a breast pump for feeding your child, how can you know what the best breast pump is?
Is manual better?
What is the best electric breast pump?
To help, we went shopping for you and built a list of our top choices of the best breast pumps in 2018 to help make buying a breast pump as easy and pain free as possible.
If you’re ready, we’d like to show you our recommended choices for the 10 best breast pumps in 2018.
Let’s get started.
QUICK ANSWER: THE BEST BREAST PUMPS
- 1. S2 Double/Single Breast Pump by Spectra Baby USA
- 2. Harmony Manual Breast Pump by Medela
- 3. Quiet Expressions Double Breast Pump by The First Years
- 4. Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump with On the Go Tote by Medela
- 5. Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump Starter Set by Medela
- 6. AVENT Comfort Double Electric Breast Pump by Philips
- 7. S1 Double/Single Breast Pump with Rechargeable Battery by Spectra Baby USA
- 8. AVENT Manual Comfort Breast Pump by Philips
- 9. Effective Pro Double Electric Breast Pump with Independent Dual Control by BelleMa
- 10. Swing Breast Pump by Medela
Breast Pumps Reviews
1. S2 Double/Single Breast Pump by Spectra Baby USA
The S2 is one of the most talked about breast pumps on the market today and it is easy to see the appeal. With the power to express the best quality breast milk at a fraction of the price, the S2 from Spectra Baby USA is a quality piece of hospital grade equipment.
Ensuring that the breast milk expressed won’t run the risk of being contaminated by the other parts of the pump, the S2 is a completely closed system. In order to do this, Spectra has built a physical barrier between the milk and the pump that will guarantee not only motor performance, but also hygiene when it comes to the milk you’re feeding your little one.
Boasting a suction strength of 300mmHg and its ability to be used as a single pump or dual, the touch buttons digital controls of the S2 make it easy to use. Running at a near silent capacity, features such as a timer, a nightlight and the ability to adjust both the cycle (pump “sucking” rate) and the vacuum (suction strength) allow you to pump easier and more successfully.
Why we love it – The S2 is a quality breast pump that for the price, can give you a hospital grade pump at a non-premium price. With the built in barrier and features that the machine offers moms looking to express milk comfortably and successfully, the S2 is our top rated breast pump.
2. Harmony Manual Breast Pump by Medela
Even with the advances in breast pumping technology, there are some mothers who feel apprehensive about using an electric breast pump. For those who feel this way, Medela offers the Harmony as a mom recommended manual option.
With its 2-phase expression technology, the pump can be used to stimulate and then express the milk from your breast, without losing suction from the flange. Using BPA-free bottles and a unique stand, you won’t have to worry about the bottle spilling after you use it.
With its discreet design, the Harmony can be a really good back up and also uses the same bottles that Medela’s electric pumps use.
If you’re a busy mom and you don’t want to carry around an electric breast pump all the time, the Harmony from Medela is a good portable option when you need one.
Why we love it – Between its ease of use, quiet operation and integration with the rest of Medela’s breast pump line, the Harmony is a quality breast pump to have or give as a baby shower gift.
3. Quiet Expressions Double Breast Pump by The First Years
Billed as a multitasking option for mothers, the Quiet Expressions Double Breast Pump from The First Years is built to be held in one hand while the dual pumps express milk from your breasts. While its presentation can be confusing to some, the features that are offered by this pump can change some mothers’ minds.
Using a remote control that is powered by 4 Double A batteries, the Quiet Expressions boasts 8 levels of suction that can easily be adjusted by pressing the plus (+) or minus (-) button to change the level of suction.
With its convenient travel bag, you can easily pack this pump up and bring it wherever you may need to go or even as a piece of carryon luggage if you’re traveling.
Why we love it – Despite the look of this handheld breast pump, the Quiet Expressions feature of 8 different levels of suction and easy travel tote make this a very valuable consideration for mothers of newborn babies.
4. Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump with On the Go Tote by Medela
When your baby is born, at many hospitals and birthing centers, they will have Medela units for you to use expressing milk for the first time. The good news is that once you leave the hospital, you can have a Medela unit of your very own, complete with a discreet tote bag to help carry around the parts of the pump.
Taking the Medela pump with you on the go is made much easier with two different options available, an on-the-go tote or a backpack. With either having the pump built into the bags, with an option to plug the unit in or use 8 Double A size batteries, makes traveling a much easier process as all other equipment will fit inside.
With its removable cooler bag, which holds up to 4 bottles using a freezable ice pack, you won’t have to worry about getting back home right away to put the milk you express into the fridge as this will keep the milk cold while you’re on the go.
Why we love it – The Pump in Style is a great option for moms who are looking for a hospital grade pump at home and on the go. With its portability and discreet method of transport, if you choose this pump from Medela, you cannot go wrong.
5. Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump Starter Set by Medela
If you take the pump out of Medela’s On the Go set, you will then have their Starter Set. Medela has taken the most important part of their other product and made it available to moms who may not need the travel tote or cooler bag.
If you’re going to be expressing milk at home exclusively, then the Starter Set is a perfect option for you. The set comes as a dual pumping kit and is packaged with their PersonalFit breast shields, and tubing that connects from the pump to their 2-bottle system.
Using a patented 2-phase system to express breast milk, in order to express milk for your baby, you start phase 1 with a simple touch of a button to get started, while phase 2 requires you to adjust the control knob in order to manage the speed rate the pump works as well as the strength of the suction or vacuum of your breasts.
Why we love it – The Starter Set from Medela has the most important parts of its upgraded cousin. With 2-phase expression and gives you a quality breast pump that you can use at home for years to come. We recommend this for any mom who is looking for a quality breast pump that they can use every day without issue.
6. AVENT Comfort Double Electric Breast Pump by Philips
Philips AVENT line provides moms will lots of quality products to help take care of their newborns. The AVENT Comfort Double Electric Breast Pump is no different.
Due to its unique design, pumping is more comfortable than it is using pumps from other brands, with a soft cushion that gently massages your breast to stimulate the flow of milk.
While other pumps have an adjustable dial to control the strength of the suction on your breast, the AVENT has 3 easy to use settings: low, medium and high which can be set after you start pumping in the device’s gentle stimulation mode.
Using BPA Free bottles and coming with a simple travel bag will make it easy to take with you when you may need to pump while taking care of other errands. The only downside is that the AVENT needs to be plugged in and doesn’t have a secondary option of using batteries to operate.
Why we love it – Philips AVENT line is a quality brand that a lot of moms trust when it comes to feeding their baby breast milk. The Comfort Double Electric is an extension of that brand and if you’re looking for a trusted brand of equipment for your breast feeding needs, you will not be disappointed with this pump.
7. S1 Double/Single Breast Pump with Rechargeable Battery by Spectra Baby USA
Nearly identical to Spectra’s S2 breast pump, the S1 has the benefit of having a rechargeable battery pack inside of it, which the S2 does not. While both feature the same closed system with a physical membrane to help ward off any possible contamination from the pump itself, the S1 has a more powerful suction capacity of 350 mmHg, compared to the S2’s 300mmHg.
Being a rechargeable option may be an important selling feature to you. Being able to charge this and go instead of being forced to plug it into an outlet can mean the difference between pumping at home and pumping while you’re out.
Why we love it – The S1 is as quality a breast pump as its cousin, the S2. Having a hospital grade breast pump that is also rechargeable can make it easier for you to pump on the go. While the S1 has a more powerful suction that the S2, we feel that it’s the rechargeable battery that makes them stand apart.
8. AVENT Manual Comfort Breast Pump by Philips
The comfort that the Philips AVENT line put into its electric breast pump line has now been made available on a manual pump. Featuring the same soft cushioned flange to help massage your breast to stimulate the creation of milk for your baby is a nice option to have in a manual pump.
If you have decided that you may not exclusively feed from pumping or need and option when you’re out and your breasts may need to be expressed to offer some relief, the Manual Comfort Breast Pump is a good option for you.
At a much cheaper price point than Philips electric variety, the Manual Comfort can fit perfectly into a shoulder bag and doesn’t come with the parts that you would need to carry with the other option.
With the AVENT line’s feature of being able to sit more comfortably while expressing milk continues here as well. Most pumps require you to lean forward to position yourself in the best way for optimum milk production. With its unique design, you can sit up straight and successfully express milk for your child.
Why we love it – The Manual Comfort is the perfect option for moms who may not be exclusively pumping for their child so that they can have some relief if they happen to be away from home. Its smaller size also makes it easy to pack into a shoulder or any other type of bag, making transport simple.
9. Effective Pro Double Electric Breast Pump with Independent Dual Control by BelleMa
Featuring an adjustable 9 levels of suction power, with a vacuum power of up to 240 mmHg, the Pro Double from BelleMa is an affordable breast pump option for those who are interested in the S2 from Spectra Baby but aren’t comfortable with the price.
With a closed system to prevent backflow, the Pro Double has the same 2-phase pumping mechanism as other pumps on the market. Along with its soft silicone cushions that offer a gentle massage for a more comfortable pumping experience.
Why we love it – While not a “hospital-grade” breast pump like some others on our list. Its 9 level adjustable suction and memory feature that remembers your preferred setting is a welcome addition for a reasonably priced breast pump.
10. Swing Breast Pump by Medela
If you strictly breastfeed your baby and only use a breast pump sporadically, you may want to take a look at the Swing from Medela. At first glance, it has similarities with their Harmony manual breast pump.
However, the manual portion of the pump is replaced by a small handheld controlled pumping mechanism. Powered by 4 Double A batteries or plugged directly into an outlet, the Swing comes with the same 2-Phase technology that appears in Medela’s other offerings on the market and comes with easy to use controls to adjust the rhythm and force of the vacuum.
Why we love it – With its compact size and different power options, The Swing from Medela is a good choice for you if you don’t pump very often. It is also lightweight and can easily fit into a small bag for easy transport.
How We Chose the Top Breast Pumps in Our List
We understand that there are a lot of different options on the market when you choose to buy a breast pump. But how do you know what is the best breast pump out there for your needs? When we sat down to compile our list, we wanted to make sure that we used what we as well as other moms felt were important features to have in a breast pump. Here are the criteria we used to build our top 10.
When your baby breastfeeds, to help you produce milk, they go through 2 phases. The first phase involves stimulation of your breast where your baby takes short, shallow, frequent sucks to try and produce milk. The second phase is where your baby suckles longer and deeper, this is also known as expression. Having a breast pump that can do both phases is very beneficial to you and your baby.
The flange, otherwise known as the plastic piece that goes over your breast while pumping needs to fit properly. A lot of breast pumps on the market offer different sizes you can try so you can get an optimal fit. If the flange doesn’t fit correctly, it could lead to bleeding, pain or even an infection. For help getting the best fit, you can contact a lactation consultant if you have concerns.
When the breast pump was first given a U.S. Patent, it wasn’t exactly what you would call compact. Thankfully, today’s versions can make it easy for you to take it along with you if you are out and about or traveling and need to pump. We wanted to make mobility a key for those moms who may have to go back to work or may be out and about and need to pump.
Manual vs. Electric
Breast pumps can be purchased in either format. We wanted to take into account the benefits of how an electric breast pump can be beneficial to you as well as the benefits of using a manual breast pump when we were compiling our top 10 choices.
Different Types of Breast Pumps
Regardless of the type, any breast pump on the market should come with BPA-free bottles that you can pump into directly, that are also dishwasher safe, when on the top rack. For pumps that are electric, the controls can adjust the suction power and speed. Breast pumps generally break down into three different categories when you start to look at them:
Hospital Quality Electric Pumps
As a heavy duty breast pump option, these types of pumps come with powerful motors that can produce more extractions per minute. The turnaround time is generally very quick and the noise that these types of pump make can be very minimal. These can be a very expensive option, sometimes costing around $1,000.
Personal Electric Breast Pumps
For most moms in today’s professional world, having a baby means taking maternity leave and going back to work after 6 or 8 weeks. For those moms, breast pump makers offer a double, electric, personal breast pump that can efficiently pump milk from both breasts at the same time. A major feature for this type of pump is a carrying case that can hold the pump mechanism as well as the battery or electrical plug to power the device. What’s great about this is that the case doesn’t look like a breast pump and has a natural look as a tote or a backpack.
Manual Breast Pumps
With a manual breast pump, the pumping action happens just as it sounds, manually. Some mothers do prefer these for when they are out and about or traveling so that they have a more quiet option to use when they need to occasionally pump milk.
Regardless of which type of breast pump you select, all types have what’s known as a breast shield that covers the breast while you are pumping to achieve the best suction. Some models on the market offer different sizes for you to try out to ensure a proper fit. No matter which you decide to go with, most insurances should be able to cover the costs of the breast pump you want to use.
Breast Pump Benefits
Using a breast pump can have many benefits when it comes time to feed your little one. Learning what the benefits are before you choose the right breast pump for you will help make the decision on which one to purchase that much easier. Benefits of using a breast pump include:
Now when you read that, if you’ve never used one before, you may not think that a breast pump can help relieve pain. Not true. Continuously using a breast pump can help save a mother from the pains of their breasts engorging and becoming heavier as they produce milk that needs to be expressed. With pumping, this can be done anytime, unlike strictly breast feeding where you would need to wait until it’s time to feed your little one again.
Ease of extraction
Using a breast pump, whether manual or automatic, can make milk extraction a much easier process. Being able to sit, in comfort and allow the pump to extract food for your baby can be a more stress free experience than attempting to have them latch onto your breast unsuccessfully.
For some women, breast pumping or even breast feeding in public can make them very uncomfortable. With a breast pump, you can pump in comfort of your own home without any concerns of people staring at you or maybe even having an issue with your pumping or even breastfeeding in public.
Reducing Latching Problems
Many moms have a hard time getting their new little bundle of joy to latch onto their breast when it’s time to eat. With the use of a breast pump, moms can help resolve the issue by still providing their child with breast milk but from a bottle and still provide the healthy nutrients that the milk will provide their baby.
When you breastfeed your baby, it is you and your baby doing this together. While that can create an incredible bond between you, for those moms who choose to use a breast pump, feeding can become more of a joint effort between mom and dad. If feeding time corresponds to when you need to pump, the other parent can feed the little one while you pump more milk for next time.
One thing that a lot of moms wonder is how much milk is my baby getting when they breast feed? It’s a good question as there is no real way to tell. Using a breast pump extracts milk into a bottle. When feeding, you can use a separate bottle to pour milk into so you know exactly how much milk you’re giving the baby when it’s time to eat.
With that extra milk that moms pump while dad may be feeding the baby can be stored for later use. Some moms keep a continuous amount in their fridge so they can have milk on hand when it’s time to eat. Then outside of those times, they can freeze their breast milk in extra bottles or bags to have a supply that they can use if needed. Frozen breast milk can be good for 4 to 6 months.
While most moms may not cite this as an obvious benefit, it is a huge benefit. If you decide to not breastfeed and instead bottle feed your child, you could use formula instead of breast pumping first. Baby formula, whether its in poweder or liquid can be expensive and add up very quickly. According to the Breastfeeding Center of Ann Arbor, they calculated that feeding primarily using formula can cost more than $1100 a year.
That’s a lot of money that you can put back in your pocket if your choose to use a breast pump instead.
For some moms who have issues with their baby latching on and breast feeding, pumping milk to then bottle feed their little one still offers them a lot of the same nutritional benefits that they would normally receive. This wouldn’t be the case if your baby was being strictly fed formula as some nutritional benefits can only be found in a mother’s breast milk.
Understanding the Breastfeeding vs. Breast Pumping Conversation
Before you start to feed your baby, whether it is from your breast or from the bottle using milk that you have pumped in order to feed them, it is important to understand both sides of the argument between breastfeeding and breast pumping to feed your child.
Mothers who side towards breastfeeding their babies exclusively cite the closeness or bond that can be developed between you and your child while they breastfeed. Some have pointed out the convenience that comes with breastfeeding as well as the nutritional benefits that come with the milk coming straight from you to your baby.
However, moms who pump exclusively, while they do agree on a lot of the points made by those who are pro-breastfeeding, also see pumping as a way to build a supply of milk for their child. With moms who pump exclusively to feed their children, the nutritional value of the milk they produce does not decline that much.
A detraction of feeding your baby via breast pumping is that having to carry around a pump to extract milk for them can become a bit arduous. Have to carry around the pump all the time and find a place to pump milk can become a hassle.
Choosing what’s best for you
When you start the process of shopping for a breast pump, you want to make sure that you do your research first on the different options out there.
With a lot of different options on the market, choosing the best breast pump for you will be about what preferences you are looking for in a breast pump. You do want to make sure that whichever one you choose fits securely and comfortably to ensure the best possible experience and to avoid any injuries that may arise from misuse.
We hope that our list of the 10 Best Breast Pumps in 2018 was able to give you some options to consider when choosing a breast pump. While there are a lot of choices out there, we’re confident that the list we’ve provided you with will be able to help you in that endeavor.
Choosing the best breast pump to help feed your baby is an important decision. You’re not only choosing a method of expressing the milk from your breast, but you’re also choosing how your baby is fed. This decision is one of the most important ones that you can make as a mom.
Do you have a Breast Pumps on our list? Let us know how you like it in the comment section below.
Last Update on the 8th of March 2017